Conditions

Great Toe Arthritis (Hallux Rigidus)

Hallux rigidus refers to arthritis affecting the joint at the base of the big toe, representing the most prevalent arthritic condition in the foot. It commonly affects individuals over the age of 30, with women being more susceptible than men. The joint in question, termed the hallux metatarsophalangeal (MTP) joint, connects the first foot bone (metatarsal) with the base of the first toe bone (proximal phalanx) and two small bones underneath the metatarsal. Typically, the most significant wear occurs at the top of this joint.

Symptoms

Pain in the big toe joint during activity, particularly when pushing off to walk, is a hallmark symptom of hallux rigidus. Swelling around the joint and difficulty bending the toe may also be experienced. Over time, a bony bump, similar to a bunion or bone spur, may develop atop the joint, aggravating discomfort by rubbing against footwear.

Causes

The precise cause of hallux rigidus remains unclear, although several risk factors have been identified. These include variations in foot anatomy (flatfeet, high arched, etc.), such as a long or elevated first foot bone, previous injury to the big toe, and familial predisposition. These factors contribute to excessive wear of the joint, ultimately leading to arthritis.

Diagnosis

In many instances, a diagnosis of hallux rigidus can be established through a physical examination. Dr. Kamel will assess the mobility of the MTP joint and pinpoint areas of pain. Additionally, the presence of bone spurs may be evaluated. X-rays, preferably taken with weight-bearing, are typically employed to assess joint degeneration and the size and location of bone spurs. MRI and CT scans are rarely necessary for diagnosis.

Treatment

Non-Surgical Treatment

Initial management of hallux rigidus typically involves non-surgical approaches. These may encompass pain-relieving medications, anti-inflammatory drugs, and applications of ice or heat to alleviate discomfort. Injections of platelet-rich plasma into the joint show promise but vary in efficacy. Footwear modifications, such as opting for shoes with stiff or curved soles, can help reduce pressure on the joint. Inserts and arch supports may also limit motion at the MTP joint, providing relief.

Surgical Treatment 

If non-surgical interventions fail to alleviate symptoms, surgical options may be explored based on the severity of arthritis and toe deformity.

  • Cheilectomy: For mild to moderate cases, removing bone and spurs from the top of the foot and big toe (cheilectomy) can enhance toe mobility and alleviate pain.
  • Arthrodesis (Joint Fusion): In advanced stages with significant joint damage, fusing the big toe joint (arthrodesis) may be necessary to reduce pain. This procedure restricts toe movement but provides lasting pain relief.
  • Interpositional Arthroplasty: An alternative for moderate to severe cases involves removing damaged bone and placing a spacer between the bones to minimize joint contact.
  • Arthroplasty (Joint Replacement): While joint replacement has shown success in other joints, its application in hallux rigidus remains limited due to concerns regarding complications and unpredictable outcomes.

Recovery

Recovery duration varies depending on the type of surgery performed. Most patients can resume normal activities after a period of immobilization and rehabilitation. Stiff-soled footwear may provide added comfort during exercise.

Risks and Complications

As with any surgery, there are risks, including infection and scarring, although they are rare with these procedures. Factors such as smoking or compromised immunity may increase these risks. Consultation with Dr. Kamel is essential for personalized guidance.

Make An Appointment

If you're experiencing any foot or ankle conditions, we’re here to help. Schedule an appointment today to get the care you need.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can hallux rigidus get worse over time?

es, hallux rigidus, a condition characterized by arthritis and stiffness in the big toe joint, can worsen over time if left untreated or if the underlying factors contributing to the condition are not adequately managed. Hallux rigidus is a progressive condition, meaning it tends to worsen gradually over time, although the rate of progression can vary from person to person.

Several factors can contribute to the worsening of hallux rigidus over time:

  1. Degenerative changes:
    Hallux rigidus is often caused by degenerative changes in the cartilage of the big toe joint, leading to loss of cartilage, joint inflammation, and bone spurs (osteophytes). These changes can progress, resulting in increased pain, stiffness, and decreased range of motion in the joint.
  2. Poor foot mechanics:
    Abnormal foot mechanics, such as excessive pronation (flat feet) or a high arch, can place increased stress on the big toe joint, exacerbating the degenerative process and accelerating the progression of hallux rigidus.
  3. Overuse or repetitive stress:
    Activities that involve repetitive stress on the big toe joint, such as running, jumping, or prolonged standing, can contribute to the progression of hallux rigidus by further damaging the joint structures and speeding up the degenerative process.
  4. Inadequate treatment:
    Without proper treatment and management, hallux rigidus symptoms can worsen. Failure to address contributing factors such as footwear choices, activity modifications, and underlying foot deformities can lead to continued joint deterioration and worsening symptoms.
  5. Delayed diagnosis:
    If hallux rigidus is not diagnosed and treated in its early stages, the condition may progress to more advanced stages, making it more challenging to manage conservatively and potentially necessitating more invasive treatment options, such as surgery.

While hallux rigidus is a progressive condition, there are various conservative and surgical treatment options available to manage symptoms, slow its progression, and preserve joint function. These may include:

Early intervention and proactive management are key to slowing the progression of hallux rigidus and maintaining optimal foot function and mobility. If you suspect you have hallux rigidus or are experiencing symptoms such as pain, stiffness, or limited range of motion in the big toe joint, it's essential to consult with a healthcare provider or foot specialist for an accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment recommendations.

How do I choose between cheilectomy, joint replacement, and joint fusion for hallux rigidus?

Choosing between cheilectomy, joint replacement, and joint fusion for the treatment of hallux rigidus depends on several factors, including the severity of the condition, the patient's age, activity level, foot anatomy, and personal preferences. Each surgical procedure has its advantages, limitations, and potential risks. It’s essential to discuss these options thoroughly with Dr. Kamel to determine the most appropriate treatment approach.

Comparison of Cheilectomy, Joint Replacement, and Joint Fusion for Hallux Rigidus:

Cheilectomy:
  • Procedure: Involves removing bone spurs and damaged tissue from the top of the metatarsal bone to increase the space in the joint and relieve pressure on the damaged cartilage.
  • Advantages:
    • Preserves joint motion, allowing continued movement in the big toe joint.
    • Minimal alteration of foot anatomy and biomechanics.
    • Shorter recovery time compared to joint replacement or fusion.
  • Limitations:
    • Not suitable for advanced stages of hallux rigidus or severe joint degeneration.
    • Risk of recurrence of symptoms, especially if underlying arthritis progresses.
    • May not provide long-term relief for all patients, and revision surgery may be necessary in some cases.
Joint Replacement (Arthroplasty):
  • Procedure: Involves removing the damaged surfaces of the metatarsal and phalangeal bones and replacing them with artificial implants made of metal and plastic.
  • Advantages:
    • Restores joint function and mobility, allowing for pain-free movement in the big toe joint.
    • Preserves more of the natural joint anatomy compared to fusion.
    • Suitable for patients with moderate to severe hallux rigidus who want to maintain joint motion.
  • Limitations:
    • Not recommended for patients with severe deformity, instability, or poor bone quality.
    • Implants may wear out over time, leading to implant failure or loosening.
    • Higher risk of complications, including infection, implant failure, and stiffness.
Joint Fusion (Arthrodesis):
  • Procedure: Involves removing the damaged cartilage and permanently fusing the bones of the metatarsal and phalangeal joints using screws, plates, or other fixation devices.
  • Advantages:
    • Provides a stable, pain-free joint that can bear weight and withstand high levels of activity.
    • Eliminates pain by immobilizing the joint and preventing bone-on-bone contact.
    • Offers long-lasting relief and durability compared to other procedures.
  • Limitations:
    • Results in the loss of joint motion and stiffness in the big toe joint.
    • Alters foot biomechanics and may affect gait and balance.
    • Prolonged recovery time compared to cheilectomy or joint replacement.
Key Considerations

When deciding between cheilectomy, joint replacement, and joint fusion for hallux rigidus, it's important to weigh the potential benefits and risks of each procedure. Consider factors such as your age, activity level, lifestyle goals, and preferences for joint motion versus stability. Dr. Kamel can help guide you through the decision-making process and recommend the most suitable treatment option based on your individual needs and circumstances.

Still have questions?

Reach out directly to Dr. Kamel.

Related Products